Industry collaboration works to advance subsea processing technology

The Research Partnership to Secure Energy for America (RPSEA), operating under the direction of DOE's National Energy Technology Laboratory, is working with GE to develop subsea processing technology to lessen the need for deepwater surface production facilities and extended tiebacks.

Ge1 1411off

Roy Long
US Department of Energy

Improving safety, reliability, and performance indeepwater development are the principle goals of the US Department of Energy Office of Fossil Energy's (DOE) implementation of the Energy Policy Act of 2005. The program, created by an act of Congress and administered by the Research Partnership to Secure Energy for America (RPSEA) under the direction of DOE's National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL), funds research, with additional funding and research by industry and academic partners, in technologies key to ensuring a secure energy supply for the United States.

Research in subsea production and processing has been an important component of the program. Within the deepwater program, a series of projects undertaken jointly by RPSEA and GE have worked to develop subsea processing technology to lessen the need for deepwater surface production facilities and extended tiebacks.

The program began with development of a process simulation tool designed to modelsubsea processing systems (SPS) for oil and gas. The intent was to provide an industry standard to evaluate SPSs performance, and to help bridge technology readiness level (TRL) gaps between operation engineers and facility suppliers. The program deliverables included simulation architecture, a functional simulator, procedures and documentation, experimental validation, and experimental facility availability.

The program's key objectives included:

Objective 1. Develop a library of robust analytical unit models, with standardized interfaces, for compact separation devices operating in a subsea multi-phase flow environment. Standardized unit models allow the buildup of complex systems.

Objective 2. Develop a robust process simulator combining the analytical unit models from Objective 1 to provide for the following major features:

  • Prediction of both steady-state and transient performance
  • Expandability at the component level to accept more accurate analytical component descriptions as they become available from ongoing research and experience
  • User configurability
  • Interface with existing upstream industry-standard production simulators.

Objective 3. Develop a lab-scale test facility and testing protocols for the validation of both the analytical models and the simulator performance. This objective has importance for both developing unit models and validating the resulting system models, as well as the processes and methods used therein. This objective was accomplished through the creation and use of a test loop facility. The chosen test case is a horizontal three-phase (saltwater/oil/gas) gravity separator.

Objective 4. Develop a methodology and associated procedures for using the simulator to determine the operational envelope for various process designs. This was achieved through the development of a statistical methodology and toolkit in MATLAB, the technical computing language and interactive environment for algorithm development and data analysis.

Objective 5. Using the lab-scale test facility and protocol, simulator performance was validated by executing a test plan for evaluation over a wide range of conditions:

  • Operating envelopes
  • Transient stability
  • Process control logic.

Using the simulator to model various components of SPSs resulted in several research and development projects, among them the design of subsea electrical provision and distribution systems to power subsea processing components.

Ge1 1411off
SPS program overview. (Images courtesy GE)

AC and DC alternatives

Subsea electrification is seen as a key enabler and an integral part of the processing and control for deepwater oil and gas production. Subsea processing systems such as pumping, compression, and separation require the deployment of equipment that may include variable frequency drives (VFDs), electric motors, switchgears, and uninterruptible power supplies (UPSs) in close proximity to the loads on the seabed, connected via dry and wet mate connectors. Their control requires electric actuators and valves for "All-Electric" trees and highly reliable power supplies for communication and control at long step-out distances. For such applications, bulk electrical power needs to be effectively delivered from onshore or offshore platforms where power is generated, to electric loads on the seabed.

The main drivers for the power delivery system are very high reliability and maintainability. In addition, it is desirable that the system be efficient, low cost, and of high power density. Electric power can be transmitted and distributed over long distances either by alternating current (AC) or direct current (DC).

Ge3 1411off
Assembly of unit models into an SPS system.

Conventional HVAC system

The high-voltage AC (HVAC) power transmission and distribution (T&D) system is a mature and proven technology for land-based applications and relatively short offshore tiebacks. The system is configured differently when single load or multiple loads need to be supplied.

Single load application. There are currently two AC power transmission options to supply power to a single subsea load. For these two AC power transmission options, multiple topside VFDs and a power umbilical with multiple three-phase submarine power cables are required to supply more than one subsea load. Another potential problem is the power transmission with variable frequency, which can increase the risk of electrical resonance and is very challenging to control.

In the first option, a medium-voltage topside VFD is used to generate a variable frequency voltage, which is directly connected to a subsea motor through a submarine power cable. This option has been used in several applications such as in the BP King subsea pump project. The VFD generates medium voltage (e.g., 9 kV) and supplies all power required in the system, including the reactive power required by the submarine cable. The transmission distance is up to 27 km for a subsea pump of 1 MW at 6.6 kV. The VFD rating can be significantly high for longer distance; therefore this option is limited to power ratings up to 3 MW and distances up to approximately 40 km. In the second option, a medium-voltage (e.g., 6.6 kV) variable frequency voltage is generated by the VFD and boosted by a step-up topside transformer for transmission (e.g., 12 to 42 kV depending on the tieback distance) via a submarine cable. On the receiving end of the cable, a subsea transformer is used to step down the voltage to supply a subsea motor (e.g., 6.6 kV). This system configuration has already been successfully applied to several field developments, such as the Lufeng field in Hong Kong and Tordis Field in the North Sea. However, it is limited to shorter distances (i.e., tens of km depending on starting torque requirement).

Ge2 1411off
Unit model input.

Displaying 1/2 Page 1,2Next>
View Article as Single page

More in Subsea