Nick Terdre
Contributing Editor
The end of production from the Thames gas field and its satellites in the UK southern basin could trigger the most extensive decommissioning program yet performed in theNorth Sea. Perenco and Tullow Oil are the two operators responsible for the campaign.
Altogether, 12 fields are involved, comprising six in the Thames Complex – Thames, Bure Oscar, Bure West, Thurne, Wensum, and Yare – and six more in the greater Thames area – Arthur, Gawain, Horne, Orwell, Wissey, and Wren. They are spread out over 13 blocks and five quadrants. Cessation of production was officially declared for all the fields on May 14, 2014, ending more than 25 years of gas supply to the UK mainland via the Thames offshore infrastructure.
Original operator Arco made the first discoveries, Yare and Thames, in 1969 and 1973, respectively. However, it was not until the 1980s that gas prices and technological advances made development economical. Initially Thames, Bure Oscar, and Yare came onstream in 1986, followed by Wensum in 1987.
At start-up, the Thames field center consisted of two fixed installations, the AW wellhead platform and the AP processing platform, with 420 MMcf/d capacity (12 MMcm/d). Gas was exported to Phillips' Bacton terminal through an 89.5-km (55.6-mi), 24-in. pipeline. Thames was expected to be fully depleted in 1998, but due partly to the added satellite gas flowing through its facilities, remained in production for 16 more years. One advantage of this longevity is that decommissioning will take place under new rules introduced by the UK government in 2013 that guarantee tax relief and other advantages.
In 1990, the Welland and Tristan fields were jointly developed and tied back to Thames. Welland, which is now operated by Perenco, ceased production in 2003 and has been separately decommissioned.
Another milestone was reached in 1993 with first gas from the Orwell field. Orwell was developed with three subsea wells tied back 35 km (21.7 mi) to Thames, which at the time was the longest step-out on the UK continental shelf. Compression facilities in the shape of two 5,000-bhp units had been placed on Thames in 1989, but in 1994 a 14,700-bhp unit was added to assist recovery from Orwell and Welland. At the same time control was moved onshore to Arco's Great Yarmouth base, making Thames the first remotely controlled processing center in the UK southern gas basin.
The next satellite tieback was Gawain, a 20-km (12.4-mi) step-out, also with three subsea wells, which came onstream in 1995. It was followed in 1998 by Bure West and Deben, both single-well developments within the Thames Complex. At the same time, a riser platform, AR, was installed with a bridge-link to AP to handle the increasing number of tiebacks. Deben ceased production in 2005, but a side track was drilled in the well to bring the Thurne reserves onstream in 2008, allowing re-use of the subsea tree, pipeline, and umbilical.
In 2005, Arthur, too, had been developed with three subsea wells and Horne and Wren with one well each drilled from a wellhead platform. In 2008, Wissey started production as a single-well subsea tieback to the Horne/Wren platform. The main mover behind these developments was Arco, which operated Gawain and Orwell as well as the Thames Complex. However, after BP acquired Arco in the late 1990s, ExxonMobil took on operatorship of the complex, eventually passing it on to Perenco in 2007. However, several of the fields – Thurne, Horne, Orwell, Wissey, and Wren – are now operated by Tullow.
Full removal
Measures to prolong production, such as additional compression, greater liquid handling and subsea well stimulation, have been considered and discarded. Under current regulations, the licensees are obliged to entirely remove all the platforms. The largest is Thames AP, which has a 6,488-metric ton (7,152-ton) topsides supported on a six-legged, 1,100-metric ton (1,212-ton) jacket. The AW wellhead platform has a 2,035-metric ton (2,243-ton) topsides on a four-legged, 950-metric ton (1,047-ton) jacket. The AR riser platform features a 406-metric ton (447-ton) topsides on a four-legged, 600-metric ton (661-ton) jacket. Water depth at the field center is 32 m (105 ft).
Topsides removal will be performed by a heavy-lift vessel (HLV), single-lift vessel, (SLV) or a combination of a crane vessel and the piece-small method. The decision will be based on the bids submitted. Jacket removal will be performed by an HLV or SLV, or by attaching the structures to an up-ended barge, a method untried to date in the North Sea.
The Horne/Wren platform is a small, unmanned installation with a 90-metric ton (99-ton) deck supported by a 455-metric ton (501-ton), tripod jacket in 41 m (134 ft) of water. Following a conceptual platform removal study by Xodus in 2013, the platform will be removed by reverse installation.
On Thames itself, there are five platform wells to be P&A'd, comprising three producers and two water disposal wells. One of the producers was drilled into Wensum. A rigless method will be used to plug the platform wells. There are also five subsea wells, one each for the four fields in the complex, plus a suspended subsea well located beneath the AW platform.
In the fields outside the Thames Complex there are a further 12 wells to be plugged – 10 subsea and two platform drilled. There are also subsea structures on the Arthur, Gawain, and Orwell fields. The Arthur wells are tied into a manifold while the wells on Gawain and Orwell are each housed on a template/manifold. The structures vary somewhat in weight. The Arthur manifold weighs 23 metric tons (25 tons) with a protection frame of 355 metric tons (391 tons). The Orwell template weighs 250 metric tons (275 tons) and the protection frame in which the manifolds are incorporated, another 200 metric tons (220 tons).
Templates, manifolds, and protection structures will be retrieved and disposed of onshore. However, a survey of the pipelines and umbilicals, including the export pipeline to Bacton, showed that they are trenched and buried, and should therefore be left in place after flushing and cleaning and cutting off any exposed ends.
Stabilization materials such as rock, frond mats, and grout bags will be assessed for integrity and burial depth, although the bulk of this material will also likely be left in situ. Attempts will be made to remove the concrete mattresses safely, but if these fail, a proposal will be made to leave them in place.
There is no recommendation concerning drill cuttings piles. Due to the strong seabed currents in the shallow waters of the Thames area, no cuttings piles have been found, so they are all presumed to have been dispersed.
The overall cost for the multi-field program is estimated at £221.5 million ($336 million). Decommissioning the Thames field center and complex will cost £96.1 million ($145.9 million), or 43% of the total, with the platform removals costing £43 million ($65 million) and the well P&A another £40 million ($60.7 million).
Of the outlying fields, Arthur will be the most expensive to decommission, with an estimated cost of £44.1 million ($66.9 million), of which the P&A accounts for £33 million ($50.1 million). Then comes Gawain, with an overall cost of £31.8 million ($48.3 million), of which P&A is £25 million ($37.9 million), followed by Orwell at £19.5 million ($29.6 million), with P&A accounting for £14 million ($21.2 million). For Horne and Wren, the estimated cost is £21.5 million ($32.6 million), of which platform and pipeline decommissioning account for £13 million ($19.7 million).
Decommissioning operations such as well abandonment will be coordinated on the various fields where possible. Activities were due to get underway in the latter months of 2014 and are expected to be completed by 2018.
